Dear Richard Hickock,
We
are sharing a doom against which virtue was no defense. This is your entire
fault, only if I had listened to Willie Jay I would be out there chasing my
dreams and not stuck here with these people. I despise guys who cannot control
themselves, and let me tell you that you are that guy. You had a decent
childhood and there was no reason to rob that innocent family. I believe there
got to be something wrong with you, for what you did. And why in the world are
these people telling me that I shot the Clutters? I mean aren’t Clutters still
alive? Oh wait?! Don’t tell me you shot them down after you told me that you
left something back at home? Like you always said no witnesses, well now you
got us in a lot more trouble, thanks to your stupid idea. Dick let me tell you
this, its not shame to have a dirty face- the shame come when you keep it
dirty. Dick you don’t have to act like a dick, just tell them I had nothing to
with the killing of Clutters. I don’t want to get in trouble for something,
which I didn’t even know about till now. I believe in hanging, as long as I am
not the one being hanged. I fear death Dick, even though I didn’t have a
pleasant childhood, I always wanted to go treasure hunting and live rest of my
life exploring. I didn’t even wanted to rob the Clutters I did all that to act
tough and get some respect in your eyes since I was never respected by anyone
but Willie Jay. Now these people are telling me that you are scared of me,
isn’t that funny? You being scared of me is like sun rising on the west. Before
going inside Clutters house I was having second thoughts, and I wanted to shoot
you down, but I didn’t. But you know why I didn’t shoot you? Because when I
held that gun up it reminded me of your parents and what they will feel when
they see your dead face. I have no right to take someone’s life, but I do have
a right to make it better. If there is some humanity inside you Dick, which I
believe there is, you will tell them that I wasn’t a part of the killing of the
Clutter. Peace out.
Your partner in Crime,
Perry Smith
Hi Dagar,
ReplyDeleteI like that you've come up with some good ideas here - trying to convince Dick to take the responsibility, reflecting on Willie Jay and Perry's childhood, a desire for vengeance... The only major issue is that I wonder if these things conflict a little bit. In reading this I feel a little confused about Perry's motivation in writing it. Consider revisiting the question sheet I gave you all - what motivations did you list for Perry writing this? Do the motivations conflict at all there?
To be more specific, if he were going to try to convince Dick to take the rap, I'm not sure that he would insult him only a few sentences later. That would most likely only make Dick angry, and very unlikely to be willing to die for Perry's freedom. I recommend giving a little bit more thought to how these ideas can come together without contradicting each other. If you revise, shoot me an email to let me know and I'll take a second look and give a second round of comments.
I also think you could take a look at some of the grammar - there are only minor mistakes, but I think with some thoughtful editing (try reading it out loud as you go) you could avoid them for a much more polished final draft!